Postagens

Vorzimmer (1975); Kohn, Stauffer e Smith (1982)

Imagem
 VORZIMMER (1975) ·          This bundle of sheets [found in the cupboard after Emma’s death] contained, in fact, the following: 13 pages in ink in Darwin's hand constituting a single draft with title, section numbers, and end; 1 page, also in ink in Darwin's hand, written on both sides (one side containing an outline and a list of omissions, the other a long paragraph intended as an "introduction"; and finally, 35 pages written in pencil in Darwin's hand which comprise the entitled "Pencil Sketch of 1842." 192 ·          O doc de 13+1 pgs é o documento mencionado por Darwin como sendo de 1839? ·          Algumas notas estão presentes, provavelmente feitas em 1842. ·          Uma pg contendo o outline do draft e o uma lista de omissões e no verso uma introdução descartada por Darwin também provavelmente em 1842. · ...

Francis Darwin (1887; 1909)

Imagem
 Life and Letters of Charles Darwin v. 2 (1887). ·          A comparison of the two editions of the ' Journal' is instructive, as giving some idea of the development of his views on evolution. It does not give us a true index of the mass of conjecture which was taking shape in his mind, but it shows us that he felt sure enough of the truth of his belief to allow a stronger tinge of evolution to appear in the second edition. He has mentioned in the Autobiography (p. 83), that it was not until he read Malthus that he got a clear view of the potency of natural selection. This was in 1838—a year after he finished the first edition (it was not published until 1839), and seven years before the second edition was written (1845). Thus the turning-point in the formation of his theory took place between the writing of the two editions. 2 Segue com diversas comparações de frases entre as duas edições ·          ...

Kohn (1980)

Theories to work by: rejected theories, reproduction, and Darwin's path to natural selection . January 1980  Studies in History of Biology 4:67-70 Intro ·          Não   é possivel reconstruir o processo de darwin como um caminho gradual em direção a origem pq isso força a ignorar aspectos importantes 68 ·          Theoretical speculation, for Darwin, seems most often to be a matter of testing alternative explanations agaisnt deepley held criteria. In the case of reproduction, his “theory to work by” had to embody some aspect of reproduxtion that functions in all matings and that does not disrupt the hereditary structure of the organism. This is a simple criterion, it is also patentlu the principle of uniformity appleied to reproduction. Nevertheless, he applied it consistently once he becme a transformist. It determined which explanations he found acceptable and which he recected. 68 ·...